05The hard parts
One clock for the match
Every scored frame is a tactical frame. Any other source must be mapped onto that clock before it can testify, and a replay makes the mapping run backwards. Which evidence can fix the mapping, and what the mapping must record.
- Synchronisation
- Broadcast
- Replays
- Reference clock
- The tactical frame index
- Mapping
- Per segment, with a type and an uncertainty
- Segment types
- Live, replay, slow motion, unknown
- Trap
- One global offset for a whole broadcast
The design question
Which frames from two sources show the same instant? Until that is answered, a second camera is a separate film. What the broadcast feed is, and why it cuts and replays, is described in Two cameras, two clocks. This study is about the design of the mapping: the first prerequisite of the single source of truth.
Evidence for alignment
| Evidence | Strength | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Native timecode | Exact when present | Often absent or reset at cuts |
| On-screen match clock | Readable anchor | Hidden in replays and close-ups |
| Shared audio | Dense, continuous | Needs the same audio in both feeds |
| Movement fingerprints | Uses the play itself | Ambiguous in static phases |
| Event anchors with a robust offset fit | A few good anchors fix a segment | Anchors must be independent |
| Constrained dynamic time warping | Handles drift | Invents matches without constraints |
| Learned embeddings | Aligns without hand features | Training data, opaque errors |
The mapping record
One record per broadcast segment: the tactical frame range it corresponds to, its type, the evidence that produced the link, and the timing uncertainty. Downstream stages read the uncertainty before the frame.
Uncertainty inside a segment
What breaks it in real football
- A replay is not an offset. The mapping is non-monotonic across segments, and one tactical instant can appear on screen more than once.
- Crowd shots have no match in them. A bench or the stands cannot be aligned to play. Leave them unmapped.
How to judge it
Check alignment against contact anchors that were not used to fit it: a kick-off, a header, a bounce. Report the error in frames, per segment type, and prefer an honest gap to a confident wrong link.
Our read
Synchronisation is a per-segment mapping with a confidence, never a single offset. When the evidence is thin, a candidate interval is the correct answer and a frame number is a false one.