05The hard parts

Alive or dead, then who

Whether the ball is in play and which team controls it are two different football facts. Designs that answer them with one mechanism let each corrupt the other.

  • Dead ball
  • Restarts
  • Two questions
Two lanes, two questions. A tag may hint at the team and is blocked from the alive-or-dead lane. Combined, home, dead, home counts as two possessions, never one.
Question one
Is the ball in play?
Question two
If so, which team controls it?
Design rule
The two never share evidence
Score structure
A dead ball always separates two spells

The design question

One three-way decision, or two two-way decisions? Home, away and dead look like three classes of the same kind. They are not. Dead is a fact about the match. Home and away are facts about control within live play.

The options

Design How Wins Costs
Direct three-class One model scores home, away, dead Simple, one objective Team cues leak into stoppages
Two heads Alive or dead first, then team if alive Mirrors the football logic An early error propagates
Two evidence lanes, one decoder Separate evidence, joint decode Clean evidence, coherent sequence Lanes must be kept apart by design

The Shrewdies decoder runs the third design: a tag may help decide which team, it can never lengthen or shorten a stoppage, and a unit test guarantees it. The dead-ball cues it reads are listed there.

Why the score cares

A dead ball is not a possession, and it always ends one. A stoppage that is missed merges two spells. A stoppage that is invented splits one. Either way the frame score barely moves and the ranking score does.

What breaks it in real football

Two scenes with the same motionless ball. In one a goalkeeper waits while the press arrives. In the other a wall lines up for a free kick. The ball cannot tell them apart. The players and the tag can.
  • A quick free kick. The stoppage lasts a second. A decoder with a heavy alive-or-dead cost never sees it.
  • A tag that arrives late. The ball has been dead for some time before any set-piece tag says so.

One failure belongs to another study: reading a missing ball as a stoppage is the subject of When the ball goes missing.

How to judge it

Score the alive-or-dead decision on its own, as a two-class problem, before scoring possession. Then count boundary errors by type: live to dead, dead to live, and team to team. A system can be excellent at the third and lose the match on the first two.

Our read

Separate the two questions and guard the border. Evidence about the team must never move the edge of a stoppage.

Sources

  1. More Than a Hack 2027: the challengegithub.com
  2. More Than a Hack 2027: FAQgithub.com
  3. Borghesi et al. (2023), ball possession with a temporal convolutional networkdoi.org